
Guide · November 2026
Board-on-Board vs. Side-by-Side vs. Shadowbox Cedar Fences
Board-on-board overlaps two layers of pickets, so it stays fully private as the cedar shrinks. Side-by-side butts pickets edge to edge and uses less wood, but small gaps can open as the boards dry. Shadowbox alternates pickets on both sides of the rails, so it looks the same from both yards and lets air through, with partial privacy.
By Fence Installation Dallas
The Three Styles Compared
| Feature | Board-on-board | Side-by-side | Shadowbox |
|---|---|---|---|
| Privacy | Full, even as boards shrink | Full when new; gaps can open | Partial |
| Cedar used | Most | Least | In between |
| Neighbor's side | Rails show | Rails show | Same as your side |
| Wind | Solid face | Solid face | Air passes through |
| Cost | Highest of the three | Lowest | In between |
Board-on-Board
A first row of pickets goes on with small gaps, and a second row covers the gaps. Because the pickets overlap, the fence stays private even after the cedar dries and shrinks. It's the style most Dallas homeowners ask for on 8-foot privacy fences.
Side-by-Side
Pickets are butted edge to edge in one layer. It's the simplest and least expensive privacy style. As new cedar dries over its first months, thin gaps can show between boards.
Shadowbox
Pickets alternate on the front and back of the rails, so the fence looks finished from both yards. Light and air pass through at an angle, which some owners like for the breeze, but you can partly see through it up close.
Cedar vs. Pine
Pressure-treated pine costs less, but it's more prone to warping and cracking, and it doesn't take stain as evenly. Cedar's natural oils help it resist rot and insects, which is why it's the standard privacy fence wood around Dallas.
North Texas fence builders commonly cite 15 to 25 years for a cedar fence, depending on the wood, the posts and how often it's stained or sealed. Steel posts remove the most common early failure: wood posts rotting at the ground line.
Add-Ons Worth Knowing
- Top cap and trim: boards along the top that give a finished look and shed water off the picket ends.
- Rot board: a horizontal board at the bottom that can be replaced without touching the pickets.
- Steel posts: galvanized posts set in concrete under the cedar.
- Stain: slows graying; let new cedar dry before staining.
Cedar Fence Style Questions
Which cedar fence style is most private?
Is shadowbox the same on both sides?
How long does a cedar fence last?
Is cedar better than pine for a fence?
Which style costs the least?
Sources
- Style descriptions: common North Texas cedar fence construction (board-on-board, side-by-side, shadowbox).
- Cedar lifespan: North Texas fence builders' published guidance, commonly 15 to 25 years.